Make your own free website on Tripod.com

Topic: Barnshine



Replying to:

'Barnshine' first showed up in boot form on Long Lost Surf Songs Vol. 2.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

Also: its been confirmed by the vault folks recently. That is indeed a legit edit.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

** The only difference is that in the "Barnshine" version you can faintly hear Mike love singing 'You are my Sunshine'. He sings out of tune with the rest of the music which makes me think that this could be a fan edit and not a legitimate edit. **

That seems unlikely, for two reasons.

First, in order for "Barnshine" to be a fan edit, we would have to have a tape elsewhere of Mike singing "You Are My Sunshine." We don't.

Second, every time "OMP/You Are My Sunshine" has turned up, it's been followed immediately by "Barnshine." Even on the *very first* SMILE tape that turned up back in 1980 (i.e., the Preiss tape), the two tracks -- albeit in incomplete form -- were back-to-back. A totally instrumental version of "OMP/You Are My Sunshine" (without Dennis' vocal on "Sunshine") was followed by the "Barnshine" section -- with the group's "hum, hum, hum dum de doobie do" vocals, but without Mike's "Sunshine" vocal. That's just too much coincidence! Instead, I think it's an indication the two pieces were intended to go together and Mike's vocal during "Barnshine" was cut at the same time as Dennis' lead for "You Are My Sunshine."

Unfortunately, back in 1980 and indeed until just recently, we simply weren't knowledgeable enough to recognize that two pieces were part of the same track.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

"Barnshine" is basically the section of music that you hear at the end of the Heroes and Villians 'in the cantina' mix released as a bonus track on the Smiley-Smile CD.

The only difference is that in the "Barnshine" version you can faintly hear Mike love singing 'You are my Sunshine'. He sings out of tune with the rest of the music which makes me think that this could be a fan edit and not a legitimate edit.

The term "Barnshine" is definately a name made up by fans. The section of music was not given any particular name by the band.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

Could I please get the details on "Barnshine." I've heard it mentioned, but I don't know what it is.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

Jons question about Friday Night got me thinking about another track that to me is a mystery. The Old Master Painter is always refered to as a finished track but it's only a minute or so long. Is that it? Prayer is longer (I think) and it wasn't considered a whole track (until later anyway). Would it have been coupled with something else? What's the deal?


Date: 08/3/01 09:58:28 PM

Subject: Re: Re: Re: the continuing adventuresof Barnshine

It's the exact same piece of music (even the same basic recording) as the end of the Cantina version of H&V, with an additional overdub of Mike singing the lyrics to You Are My Sunshine over it in a different melody. 4 bars have been editted out of the beginning, but that's what it is. Brian appropriated it later for use in Heroes And Villains, but it was tracked at the very same session that produced the master for the rest of My Only Sunshine, and in fact was tracked as "Part C" of that song. It has been booted, but it does not appear on any of the popular Smile boots, nor is it on SOT 16. The Barnyard reference is because in the early days of Smile booting, many boots mistakenly called the piece(minus the Mike overdub) Barnyard.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

To further the comments of my good friend Mr. Hanes, I was approached somewhere around 1995 by a gentleman who wanted to sell an acetate of "The Old Master Painter / You Are My Sunshine" which segued right into the fake "Barnyard" with "You Are My Sunshine" lyrics underneath. The fellow had purchased it, along with another acetate ("Bluebirds Over the Mountain", I believe), from a record dealer, who had obtained them from Shawn Love after Dennis died. He sent me a photcopy of the labels, which I still have somewhere. The "Barnshine" acetate had a plain white label (e.g. no studio markings), with nothing on it except the typed words "MY ONLY SUNSHINE". By that time I already had the vocal version on collector's tapes, plus the fellow wanted a significant sum of money for the acetates (more than aguy paying off the student loans from his MBA could afford!), so I passed on it, and referred him to Peter Reum. I believe Peter went halfies with David Leaf, and they purchased the acetate. From what I understand, David subsequently gave it to Brian Wilson for his personal collection. Since the master tape has supposedly turned up missing, the acetate is likely the best (and possibly only) source for "My Only Sunshine". (Off the subject, but Shawn apparently ended upselling a number of Dennis' acetates after he died; in addition to these two, I know of acetates of "Slip On Through" (mono/stereo), "Slip On Through" (Murry &Carl 3rd mix), "Cabinessence" (stereo 20/20 mix), "San Miguel" (in-progress dub w/o castanets), and "Surf Again" (early version of "Do It Again") that allegedly came from Shawn one way or another. There were probably more...) Lee

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

Are you asking what is barnshine? If so, the answer is, that it is the tag, of what once was know as, barnyard, and is now commonly refered to as, the false barnyard. The version in question, incorporates the Hum-be-dum-be-do chorus and strings and instrumentation with Mike Love singing You Are My Sunshine, under, and counter to the hum-be-dum-be-doo,riffs. It was connected to the first version of the Dennis vocal, You Are My Sunshine that I ever possessed. I named it Old Master Painter/You Are MySunshine/Sunyard Barnshine, the barnshine part stuck, and when years later, Jon Hunt emerged into his glory,as co-moderator of the SMiLE Shop, he and I exchanged that information, lo, those many years ago! Back inthe day, when one got a copy, of the OMP/YAMS, even the non Dennis vocal version, the humbedumbedoo, was always a part of it. Later on that chorus started turning up as an independant piece of it's own, though we now know it isn't.(I think!?) I am not refering to the tag to part one of H&V, there is a distinct difference, between the two. When the reference tapes were compiled for Capitol, the barnshine portion, went strangely missing. Maybe Mark Linett knows what happened, and maybe he doesn't. It's just a thought, nd complete conjecture on my part.

--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---

Replying to:

I was just reading the earlier post about Barnshine and now I'm becoming confused. I've always thought that it was OMP, have I missed something? The version of 'OMP/you are my sunshine' that I have is 1 minute and 9 seconds long, is this too short? I thought I had everything. Sorry to drag this up again but could somebody please either detail exactly what it sounds like or point to where I could find it on the web.



Back to the Message Board Archive
HOME